| All-American | Year | Team |
| Kevin Hover | 2007 | |
| Academic All-American | ||
| Sean Hover | 2006 | |
| Greg Ives | 2009 | |
| All State (Coaches Selection) | ||
| Joe Calabro | 2004 | 1st team |
| Mickey Hover | 2004 | 2nd team |
| Jim Yetter | 2004 | Honorable Mention |
| Jim Yetter | 2005 | 1st team |
| Joe Calabro | 2005 | 1st team |
| Steve Watson | 2005 | Honorable Mention |
| Justin DeLuca | 2005 | Honorable Mention |
| Ryan Butler | 2006 | 1st team |
| Mike Yetter | 2006 | 1st team |
| Sean Hover | 2006 | 2nd team |
| Kevin Hover | 2007 | 1st team |
| Jay Salasko | 2007 | 1st team |
| Steve Watson | 2007 | 1st team |
| Mike Yetter | 2007 | 1st team |
| Will Treichler | 2007 | 2nd team |
| Kevin Hover | 2008 | 2nd team |
| Rudy Butler | 2009 | 2nd team |
| Mark Yetter | 2010 | 1st team |
| Mark Treichler | 2010 | 2nd team |
| Kevin Wanke | 2010 | 2nd team |
